For a Jewish couple, ending a marriage often means obtaining two divorces, rather than just one. First, there is the civil divorce decree obtained from a state court, and second, there is the religious divorce recognized by the community. The latter depends on a document called a 'get' — a Jewish bill of divorce — and without it, a person who observes tradition may not be free to remarry within the faith, regardless of what the state says.
This issue matters to many families. The Pew Research Center estimated that there were 7.5 million Jewish adults and children in the United States in 2020, using a broad definition that encompasses Jewish identity based on religion, ancestry, or culture. The consequences of stalled religious divorce are significant: a 2025 Jewish News Syndicate survey of almost 400 women from 11 countries who had experience with Jewish divorce proceedings revealed that 45.5% had experienced get refusal, while nearly one-third had faced pressure to relinquish custody, financial rights, or legal representation. However, this survey was an international convenience sample and does not reflect how common this issue is within the U.S. population. Even so, it shows that the problem is real.
That's why it's important to find a Jewish family law attorney who understands both the civil courts and the religious process. Here's what you need to know:
Key takeaways
- A civil divorce and a religious get are two distinct processes, and both are usually required.
- In the case of S.I. v. M.I. (New Jersey, 2024), the court upheld a rabbinical ruling that ordered the husband to provide a get under the state's arbitration act.
- In the 2023 Connecticut case of Tilsen v. Benson, the court refused to enforce the ketubah as a prenuptial agreement, but awarded $5,000 per month in alimony for 15 years.
- The standard halakhic prenup of the Beth Din of America provides for arbitration and $150 per day in support during separation.
Table of Contents
What is a get, and why does it matter so much?
Under Jewish law, a get is the document that dissolves a marriage. It is given by the husband and received by the wife through a beis din, which is a rabbinical court made up of qualified judges who oversee religious matters.
Here's the thing: A state judge can grant you a civil divorce decree, regardless of whether your spouse cooperates. However, a get traditionally requires the husband to give it willingly. If he refuses, his wife becomes an agunah, or a "chained" woman, who cannot remarry in a religious ceremony, even though she is legally single in the eyes of the state.
This isn't just a symbolic problem. For someone whose community and future family life depend on religious recognition, being denied a get can control the rest of her life. It is also sometimes used as leverage — a way to secure a better custody or financial settlement during an already painful divorce.
So, what can civil courts actually do about issues rooted in religious law? More than you might think, but with limitations.
How civil courts can help with a religious divorce
American courts cannot order someone to be religious or interpret Jewish doctrine — the Constitution prevents the state from doing so. However, courts can enforce agreements that people have entered into freely, and this has led to some significant rulings.
In the case of S.I. v. M.I. (No. A-2160-22, 2024), the New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division reversed the decision of a lower court and confirmed a rabbinical arbitration award that required the husband to provide a get. The court relied on the New Jersey Arbitration Act (N.J.S.A. 2A:23B-1 to -36) in reaching this decision. The court treated the religious ruling as it would any other arbitration decision agreed by the parties.
In Ava Satz v. Allen Satz (New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate Division, 2023), a year earlier, the court had upheld orders requiring a husband to participate in beis din proceedings and sign an arbitration agreement. How could the court do this without crossing the church-state boundary? Because it was enforcing his own voluntary marital settlement agreement, not interpreting religious law.
New York has its own tools. Under the state's Domestic Relations Law, judges can consider the 'barriers to remarriage' that a spouse creates. In the reported case of Mizrahi-Srour v. Srour (New York Appellate Division, 2016), the court ruled in favor of maintenance of $100 per week for a period of five years. This amount was set to double to $200 per week if the husband did not provide a 'get' within 60 days — a means of addressing the economic consequences of refusal.
However, these powers have limits, and this surprises many people.
The Limits: What a Court Won't Do
Not all religious documents are valid in a civil court. Take the ketubah, for example, which is a traditional Jewish marriage contract. Some people assume that it functions in a similar way to a prenuptial agreement. However, courts don't always agree.
In Tilsen v. Benson (Connecticut Supreme Court, 2023), the court refused to enforce the ketubah as a prenuptial agreement. The reason for this was that determining the meaning of these terms would have required the court to interpret Jewish law, which it is not permitted to do. However, the court did affirm a civil alimony award of $5,000 per month for 15 years. Therefore, while the marriage ended with financial terms, they were not derived from the religious document.
Courts also exercise caution when a get order appears to compel a religious act. In the 2019 New York Appellate Division case of Cohen v. Cohen, the court removed an order requiring the husband to provide a get under Domestic Relations Law § 253, as well as a condition tying his receipt of $8,751.32 in marital property to delivering it.
What's the lesson? Outcomes can vary significantly from state to state, depending on how an agreement is worded. What works in New Jersey might not be accepted in Connecticut. Consult a local attorney to find out how courts in your state handle these matters.
Do you need a Jewish lawyer? Heritage Web can put you in touch.
The Halakhic Prenup: Your Best Protection
The most practical step a couple can take is to sign a halakhic prenuptial agreement before any problems arise. These agreements are designed to prevent get refusal from the outset.
According to the Beth Din of America, the standard version provides for the arbitration of get-related disputes and sets support at $150 per day during any period of separation. This daily obligation ceases if the wife does not comply with the Beth Din's directives — the agreement is designed to encourage both parties to reach a resolution, not to punish. Because the agreement is based on arbitration and voluntary consent, it resembles the arbitration award and settlement agreement that New Jersey courts enforced in the cases above, although those rulings did not involve this prenup itself and other states may differ.
Here are a few things you should know about these agreements:
- They are most effective when signed before the wedding, when both parties are in agreement and there is no conflict.
- They are most effective when drawn up so that a civil court can enforce them as a contract rather than as a religious ruling.
- Help is available at little or no cost. The Organization for the Resolution of Agunot (ORA) provides a free prenuptial agreement signing and notarization service at its New York office, and lists a helpline at 844-673-5463.
Even if you're already married, it's not too late to talk to a rabbi and a lawyer about drawing up a postnuptial agreement. Rules on state contracts differ, so seek local advice before signing anything.
Custody, Coercion and Keeping the Pressure Honest
Get disputes rarely happen in isolation. They are often intertwined with child custody, support and, sometimes, abuse. A withheld get can itself be a form of control.
Lawmakers have started to recognize this. In New Jersey, A1475 (P.L. 2023, c. 230), effective January 8, 2024, added patterns of coercive control to the factors a court weighs when deciding whether a domestic-violence restraining order is needed, according to the New Jersey Legislature. The law didn't create a brand-new standalone offense — but it gave judges clearer language to recognize controlling behavior, which can matter when a spouse uses a get as a weapon.
Arbitration laws are evolving too. Washington's family-law arbitration statute (SHB 1088, RCW chapter 26.14), effective January 1, 2024, lets couples arbitrate many family matters — but RCW 26.14.020 specifically excludes awards granting a civil divorce, and RCW 26.14.110 requires an arbitration stay and referral to court when certain safety concerns arise. In plain terms: arbitration is powerful, but under Washington's statute it has guardrails to protect vulnerable spouses.
With regard to custody, there is limited recent appellate guidance on disputes between observant and non-observant parents concerning the religious upbringing of children. Consequently, outcomes tend to depend heavily on the particular facts of the case and the best interests of the child in question. It is worth seeking out a lawyer who understands both the religious issues involved and the civil custody standard.
How to Choose the Right Lawyer
Not all divorce attorneys have experience with a get. When interviewing a Jewish divorce lawyer, ask them directly if they have worked with a beis din and if they know how to draft or enforce an arbitration agreement in the courts of your state.
Here are a few good questions to take to the first meeting:
- Have you ever worked on cases involving a get or a rabbinical court?
- Are you familiar with how our state treats halakhic prenuptial agreements and ketubah enforcement?
- How would you coordinate the civil case with the religious proceedings?
- What would happen if my spouse refused to cooperate with the beis din?
Geography matters here. In 2025, the Pew Research Center reported that, of U.S. adults who identify religiously as Jewish, 42% lived in the Northeast, 26% in the South, 23% in the West and 9% in the Midwest. In regions with large Jewish communities, you'll find more attorneys fluent in both systems. Elsewhere, you may need to look harder, but the right advocate is out there.
Support organizations can help you build a team. For example, the Jewish Orthodox Feminist Alliance (JOFA) maintains a directory of resources for Jewish divorce, including domestic abuse hotlines, free and low-cost legal services, children's services and beth din contacts.
Where to go from here?
If you're facing divorce or thinking ahead to marriage, it's important to get informed. The families who fare best are the ones who understand early on that the civil decree and the religious get are two separate processes. A good Jewish family law attorney can help you pursue both goals, working to protect your rights in court and your standing in the community, though the outcome also depends on your spouse's cooperation and your state's law.
Get in touch with a Jewish lawyer who understands your community. Submit your case details via Heritage Web's secure referral form.
This article provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. If you require guidance on a specific situation, please consult a qualified attorney.