Jewish Family Law Attorney Guide: Halacha and Civil Law

When facing divorce, Jewish families often require both a civil divorce and a religious get. This guide explains what a get is, how courts in New Jersey, New York and Connecticut have ruled, what protection a halakhic prenuptial agreement offers and how to choose a lawyer who understands both rabbinical and civil law.

Family Civil Rights Discrimination
Jewish Family Law Attorney Guide: Halacha and Civil Law

For a Jewish couple, ending a marriage often means obtaining two divorces, rather than just one. First, there is the civil divorce decree obtained from a state court, and second, there is the religious divorce recognized by the community. The latter depends on a document called a 'get' — a Jewish bill of divorce — and without it, a person who observes tradition may not be free to remarry within the faith, regardless of what the state says.

This issue matters to many families. The Pew Research Center estimated that there were 7.5 million Jewish adults and children in the United States in 2020, using a broad definition that encompasses Jewish identity based on religion, ancestry, or culture. The consequences of stalled religious divorce are significant: a 2025 Jewish News Syndicate survey of almost 400 women from 11 countries who had experience with Jewish divorce proceedings revealed that 45.5% had experienced get refusal, while nearly one-third had faced pressure to relinquish custody, financial rights, or legal representation. However, this survey was an international convenience sample and does not reflect how common this issue is within the U.S. population. Even so, it shows that the problem is real.

That's why it's important to find a Jewish family law attorney who understands both the civil courts and the religious process. Here's what you need to know:

Key takeaways

  • A civil divorce and a religious get are two distinct processes, and both are usually required.
  • In the case of S.I. v. M.I. (New Jersey, 2024), the court upheld a rabbinical ruling that ordered the husband to provide a get under the state's arbitration act.
  • In the 2023 Connecticut case of Tilsen v. Benson, the court refused to enforce the ketubah as a prenuptial agreement, but awarded $5,000 per month in alimony for 15 years.
  • The standard halakhic prenup of the Beth Din of America provides for arbitration and $150 per day in support during separation.